Skip to main content

Guns Or Roses – A Choice Kashmir Has To Make

man riding on canoe on lake during daytime



“A stone pelter is pelting stones for his nation.” Farooq Abdullah


“Indian government should resume talks with Pakistan or be ready to lose Kashmir.” Farooq Abdullah


“Valley is losing faith in Indian Democracy.” Karan Thapar


It has become a fashion for the elite intellectuals of India to lambast every policy of the government or every action of the Indian Army in Kashmir as a fascist approach. And on top of that now they have started warning the government of India and its citizen that they are on the verge of ceding Kashmir to Pakistan. The first thing that I want to say to these pseudo seculars, pseudo-intellectuals, and pseudo nationalists is that they should stop looking at India as one big sized cake that can be sliced and distributed to anyone who comes with a knife. The thread of Unity that binds this nation may be multicolored, but it is not so weak that anyone can break it.


Today everyone is concerned about the hard stance of the government against cross border terrorism, and action against people trying to disrupt the peace in the valley. But where were these voices when Kashmiri Pandits were forcefully evicted from their homes. Farooq Abdullah’s lips were sealed at that time. Even now when he is asked to comment on Buhran Vani, he has nothing to say. Today Kashmir is burning because of false pride and vested interests of three men, Pt. Jawahar Lal Nehru, who took Kashmir issue to UNO, Sheikh Abdullah, who instigated the people of Kashmir and backstabbed Nehru in his quest for being the uncrowned king of Kashmir, and much later Farooq Abdullah who has always acted as a voice of Pakistan sitting in India.


Now I would like to take up some points made by Sagarika Ghose in her column in The Times of India. I would rebut her understanding of the situation in Kashmir and would try and expose the effort of some media personalities and politicians to destabilize a government that is working for the national pride. Allow me to take one point at a time.


1.  " The image of a Kashmiri strapped to an army jeep has been compared to the lone figure confronting a Tank in Tiananmen Square." This is one of the most absurd statements that I have come across in the Indian media in recent times. Where the brave act of the lone person in Tiananmen Square was in protest against the Chinese suppression of the protests, the Indian Army tied that man in front of the jeep to ensure that the polling booth staff can be taken to the booths safely before being beaten to death along with the escorting party of Army by hundreds of stone pelters who were ready with stones in their hands. Indian Army personal although one of the bravest, is not foolish. A soldier of the Indian Army would not even think twice when asked to attack the enemy even when odds are 100:1. But they do not consider people of Kashmir as an enemy, as opposed to the picture painted by media and politicians. At any cost, the Army would want to avoid bloodshed whether it is of a Kashmiri youth or one of their men. The question should not be why the man was tied to the army jeep? But rather why there was a need for the army to tie a man to the jeep and why the poll booth officers and staff required protection from the very citizens for whom the polls were being held?


2. "A question was raised asking why the pellet guns are being used against Kashmiri youth, and not against Jats and Gujrati Patels during their stirs? It is also perceived that every Kashmiri protester is seen as a closet Jihadi or an agent of Pakistan." This statement and the preceding question have been raised just to give more ammunition to the so-called human rights activists all over the world. Let’s try to answer the question first. First of all the Jat agitation in Haryana and Patel stir in Gujrat were for the reservation for their castes in the government jobs and not for the “Aazadi.” Even during the Jat protests when the situation went out of control and local police were not able to rein in the violent elements, the Army was called in. However, as soon as the Army was deployed agitators ran for covers. In case they would have continued the rampage I am sure the army would not have hesitated in using the Pellet guns on them. Moreover, in Gujrat and Haryana, the protesters never gathered to pelt stones at the security forces as is the case in Kashmir. I would once again like to state that a soldier of the Indian Army never wants to shed blood of the civilians. But at the same time army would not want to lose its brave soldiers to the stones pelted by misguided, deluded, and foolish youth of Kashmir who abandon their studies and take to streets with covered faces with stones in hand, to attack their protectors.


Now about the perception about the Kashmiri Protester; I would like to raise a few questions here. Why is the Kashmiri public pelting stones only at the security forces? Not a single stone reached the doorstep of the Chief Minister of the state or any of her ministers or any of the politicians of the state who for years just sat in their lavish houses and watched Kashmir burning. Why do the protesters cover their faces when they are true nationalists and are doing this for their country? The answer to the above two questions is common. It is because the presence of the Indian Army has ensured that Pakistan trained terrorists do not operate freely in the valley. Frustrate the Army and wait for them to make a mistake. That would force the government to withdraw troops from Kashmir, and that’s it. Kashmir is as good as Pakistan’s. Organizing mobs of stone pelters systematically through social media services is the doing of Agents of Pakistan and if this title offends anyone, so be it.


3.  Vajpayee was willing to speak to separatists and spoke about ‘Insaniyat.’ However, Modi is trapped in the “tourism vs. terrorism” binary. 


I would like to ask a simple question here. What has been achieved in the past by talking to Separatists or for that matter Pakistan? These separatists are the true agents of Pakistan. Not even once have I seen any of these champions of Kashmir leading any protests on the streets of Kashmir. They remain confined in the security of their houses and send the common man of Kashmir to face the Army. They say whatever Pakistan wants them to say. They incite the youth of Kashmir to take up arms against their own country and when these youths are killed by the Army, they further fuel the fire in the hearts of the public against the Army. The day their real faces are revealed to the public of Kashmir, half of the problem would be solved. As far as talks with Pakistan are concerned, there's only one thing that needs to be stated, Kashmir is an integral part of India and will always remain so.


And what’s wrong with the statement of Tourism vs. Terrorism. It is for the people of Kashmir to decide now whether they want to support terrorism and keep facing off violently with the armed forces or they want to bring a change in their lives as well as the lives of their children by embracing development. It is a choice between Gun and Tulips, Fire in the streets or fire in their stoves, raining bullets or raining tourists, destruction, or development. Because one thing is certain, Kashmir would continue to be a part of India and our Army is more than capable of fighting the Pakistani terrorists as well as stone-pelting Kashmiri youth.


4. "It is being touted that with the advent of Narendra Modi at the center and an overall resurgence of BJP across India, has lead to a rise of Hindutva Nationalism. A call for Hindu Rashtra has been given and minorities are being targeted." This may be true to some extent but stating that beef eater, rationalist, and slogan-shouting students are unacceptable to Hindutva Nationalism is an exaggeration. First and foremost, the slogan-shouting student who is being referred to is the one who was talking about breaking India. Just because the Constitution of India gives everyone a Right to Speech; it doesn’t mean that you can use it to weaken the nation. And about rationalists, who is a rationalist? Just crying foul in the name of Human Rights whenever a terrorist dies at the hands of soldiers and not caring a bit when our jawans are slain by the same terrorists. Appeasing minorities at the cost of the majority population just to create a vote bank. Is that rational? The truth is that we have become accustomed to the corruption in our system and do not want to change the status quo. But now that there is a government in India led a leader who wants to challenge and break this corrupt system, the pseudo seculars and pseudo rationalists want to stop this change at any cost.


According to me the problem of Kashmir has had been mishandled by successive Indian governments. India and its leadership have always been trying to project itself as a peace-loving nation and a victim of terrorism. But they failed to realize that the very nations whom we are trying to convince are the ones supplying arms and money to Pakistan to continue its proxy war against us. United States’ New York Times has can come up with an article on the actions of the Indian Army in Kashmir terming them as Cruelty and cowardice. It can, even at a time when hate crimes and mass killings are at an all-time high in the USA because it knows that Indian leadership has been weak and would not retaliate. It is, therefore, high time India should shed its soft image in the international arena and starts acting tough on the issue of Kashmir. It needs to be shown to the world that Kashmir is an integral part of India, and we are capable of handling our internal affairs. India does not want any interference from a superpower of the world in its domestic issues. And those who want the USA to intervene should pack their bags and look for homes outside India.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Self-Realization (The Secret of Happiness)

" Self-Realization is the first encounter with Reality ." A simple but true statement. We spend years on this earth, lost and burdened with a load of aspirations and dreams. But for there comes a time in everyone's life when the realization struck like lightning and the entire life turns upside down. We realize that we've been chasing the wrong goals throughout our lives. Most of us spend our entire lifetimes chasing wealth, power, and materialistic joys of life and believing that achieving those goals would fill our lives with happiness. Little do we know that if happiness could be bought every rich man would be happy and poor would not be sleeping at night. However, we all know that is not true. But for the lucky ones who get a taste of this self-realization, a chance of turning around their lives presents itself.   I happened to have a similar experience. I was sitting in a restaurant with some of my friends, when suddenly in the middle of the conversation it struc

Corona Virus - A Nation's Fight Against Itself - An Open Letter to the Prime Minister

Respected Prime Minister Sir, Through this letter of mine, I would first of all like to thank you for all the efforts the government is making to combat the threat of Corona Virus in our country. Since I was not born when India went to war in 1962, 1965 and 1971 and too young to understand the complexities of it during the Kargil war, this is my first hand experience of a war like situation in the country. However, I would like to state that when you appeared on television on March 19, 2020 to address the nation, I felt assured that the government of this nation is leaving no stones unturned to ward off this threat on the lives of all the citizens of India. In fact for the first time in my life, since I’ve been able to understand the political narrative of this country, I saw politics taking a back seat and all the state governments were working with the Union government to ensure that this vicious chain can be broken. However, your reappearance on the national television to

RAM: A God Or Just A Man

We often get to hear that India is a nation of Gods. According to some theories there are approximately 36 Crore Gods and Goddesses that reside in the soul of India. Every state, every city, every town, every village in India has their own God or Goddess. Most of these Gods are revered and worshipped because of one or multiple miraculous deeds that they performed when they appeared on earth. Krishna, Shiva, Durga, Vishnu, Hanuman, Kali, Ganesh, Lakshmi and even minor Gods like, Indra, Varun, Vayu have numerous miraculous acts associated with them. Now, whether these are just stories or real miracles or if there are some other clarifications which can be given for them, we will discuss at some other time. Today I want to explore and understand a God who is not associated with any miracle throughout his appearance on earth, he couldn't fly, couldn't shift shapes and on top of that even though he is considered to be an incarnation of all powerful Vishnu, he had to depend upon a